In South Africa, the end of apartheid did not close every case involving its crimes. For families, the wait is now as much about the truth as about the democratic state’s responsibility for the absence of trials. Thabo Mbeki’s testimony before the Khampepe commission has brought the issue back to the centre of national debate.
An inquiry into cases that never went to trial
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), established in 1996, gathered testimony from victims and those responsible for apartheid-era violence. It could grant amnesty to perpetrators who fully disclosed crimes committed for political reasons. Those who did not apply for amnesty, or were not granted it, remained liable to prosecution.
Estimates vary according to the cases and criteria used. The Associated Press reports that about 300 cases were referred for investigation and possible prosecution, while an earlier tally cited nearly 150 recommended cases. In either instance, only a small proportion resulted in convictions. The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), which is responsible for criminal prosecutions, has also referred to hundreds of cases in which amnesty was not granted or had not been sought.
The inquiry chaired by retired judge Sisi Khampepe is to examine whether, from 2003 onwards, interventions obstructed investigations or prosecutions. President Cyril Ramaphosa established it in 2025, following legal action by victims’ families and years of campaigning. Former presidents Thabo Mbeki and Jacob Zuma challenged Khampepe’s participation but failed to secure her recusal.
Mbeki places responsibility on prosecutors
On 19 October 2026, in Johannesburg, the former head of state rejected allegations that his administration had ordered the abandonment of apartheid-related cases. He said he had neither directed, authorised nor approved the dropping of investigations or prosecutions. He argued that the executive could not dictate to prosecutors which cases to pursue.
His testimony comes amid allegations of political pressure by former prosecution officials and victims’ relatives. Mbeki has asked the NPA to explain why cases referred by the TRC were not dealt with. He also acknowledged meeting military and police officials from the apartheid era, but denied reaching an agreement to shield them from prosecution.
The point of contention includes Mbeki’s address to Parliament in April 2003, after the TRC submitted its final report. The former president says he opposed a general amnesty and that prosecutors retained their independence. Critics argue that arrangements discussed between prosecutors, intelligence services and potential witnesses may have blurred the line between truth-seeking and political intervention.
Mbeki also defended the use of intelligence services to verify some witnesses’ statements and uncover clandestine networks. He presents this cooperation as assistance to investigators, not a means of influencing their decisions. The commission will have to compare this account with the documents and testimony it has gathered. At this stage, the facts do not allow the allegations to be presented as established.
Delays undermine the search for truth
The delays have tangible consequences. Witnesses, suspects and relatives have died over the years. Documents and memories are becoming harder to recover. In its review of the cases, the NPA noted, among other things, cases weakened by the death of people essential to the investigations. For families, every further delay can reduce the chances of establishing the facts in court.
The issue goes beyond the responsibility of a single former president. It concerns the prosecution service’s actual independence, the continuity of investigations and the state’s ability to be held to account. In 2008, the Pretoria High Court had already ruled unconstitutional a prosecution policy that did not give priority to apartheid crimes. Subsequent court rulings and the inquiry’s work are expected to help establish who made the disputed decisions and on what basis.
The stakes are also institutional. National reconciliation enabled a political transition without widespread civil war, but it did not replace the obligation to prosecute crimes that were not covered by amnesty. Governments formed by the ANC, the party that led the democratic transition, are also being questioned over how they implemented the TRC’s recommendations.
A debate followed across southern Africa
The Khampepe commission is a South African initiative, but its examination of judicial independence and the memory of violence resonates in neighbouring countries. Within the Southern African Development Community (SADC), a regional cooperation organisation, paths out of conflict differ. The case is a reminder that a political transition does not automatically resolve the question of criminal responsibility.
What happens next will depend in part on Mbeki’s cross-examination, the date of which has yet to be set, and on the testimony of other political and judicial officials. The commission will have to distinguish between administrative decisions, failures by prosecutors and possible executive interventions. Its report will be awaited not only by families but also by South African institutions responsible for ensuring that crimes not covered by amnesty can still be investigated fairly.
The facts and statements reported here have been cross-checked against South African and international media accounts, as well as NPA documents. See the Eyewitness News report, the report by eNCA, coverage by the Sowetan, the Associated Press report and the NPA review of TRC cases.



