In Pretoria, the debate on migration is no longer confined to borders. It now touches on security, employment, public services and South Africa’s place in its own region. In a country that remains the continent’s largest economy, the way African migration is managed has become as much a political test as a matter of national cohesion.
The issue is all the more sensitive because tensions around foreigners have returned in waves for years. The violence of 2008 left 62 people dead, according to Human Rights Watch, and other major episodes followed in 2015 and then 2019, confirming that the issue is not isolated but structural.
A host country, but also a country under pressure
South Africa is a draw for migrants from the rest of the continent, particularly from southern Africa, the Horn of Africa and West Africa. This reality supports the informal economy and some sectors of trade and agriculture, but also fuels tensions in working-class neighbourhoods, where unemployment and the cost of living remain very high. The South African government itself acknowledges that concerns about irregular migration, organised crime and pressure on public services are contributing to social unease.
Against this backdrop, Cyril Ramaphosa has chosen to take the issue to the continental stage. Addressing the Pan-African Parliament in Midrand, he called on African states to tackle the root causes of migration together, citing conflicts, political instability, governance failures, poverty and social divisions. The Pan-African Parliament, an advisory body of the African Union based in South Africa, serves precisely as a forum for debates on continental integration.
Pretoria’s response: condemn hatred, regulate flows
The South African head of state condemned violence targeting migrants and described the attacks as sad and abhorrent. He said his government was fighting hatred of foreigners, xenophobia and Afrophobia. This official line echoes a message Pretoria has put forward in other recent statements: the state wants migration laws enforced, but will not allow private groups to take the place of the authorities in controlling foreigners.
The current crisis stands out for its regional scale. Several African governments have organised repatriation operations for their nationals, a sign that tensions in South Africa extend well beyond the domestic sphere. The scale of these departures remains difficult to establish precisely, as figures vary between capitals and reporting periods, but several media outlets and authorities have reported a significant movement over a few weeks, amid fear and withdrawal.
Casualty figures, too, should be treated with caution. The original text reports at least four migrants killed, while other sources describe additional deaths in recent episodes of anti-immigration tensions. What is certain, however, is that violence continues to affect African foreigners in South Africa, directly impacting families, small traders, drivers, precarious workers and communities that have long been settled in the country.
Why the issue extends beyond South Africa’s borders
Ghana has called for a debate within the African Union, while two Ghanaian nationals have petitioned the International Criminal Court over repeated attacks on migrants in South Africa. Pretoria has rejected the move, calling it opportunistic. This stand-off says something important: violence against foreigners is no longer seen solely as a local problem, but as an issue of political responsibility between African states.
For the African Union, the issue is a delicate one. On the one hand, its free-movement and economic-integration agenda depends on more permeable borders and better-organised mobility. On the other, rising local opposition is a reminder that the movement of people is not advancing at the same pace as employment, housing, security and trust in the state. In southern Africa, SADC, the Southern African Development Community, is watching these tensions closely, as they could undermine bilateral relations and cross-border labour networks.
Pretoria therefore faces a dual challenge. Domestically, the government must show that it is controlling irregular immigration without legitimising campaigns of hatred. At the continental level, it must prove that a major African country can remain an economic destination while protecting the rights of those who live and work there. It is a fragile balance, in a context where anti-migrant movements are also mobilising part of public opinion and competition for jobs weighs heavily in cities and peri-urban areas alike.
The continental significance is clear: the South African crisis is exposing the shortcomings of African mobility. It shows that no migration policy can succeed if it ignores conflicts, regional inequalities and the informal economies that absorb a large share of arrivals. It also shows that protecting African migrants is becoming a major diplomatic issue, one set to return to African Union debates and relations between Pretoria and several capitals across the continent.



