Who decides the rules that could open the doors of major South African law firms to more black lawyers? For now, the Gauteng High Court has answered on process rather than substance: the minister responsible for trade must reconsider his decision to adopt the legal-sector transformation code.
A debate rooted in the profession’s history
In South Africa, the make-up of the legal professions remains linked to the legacy of apartheid. The end of the segregationist regime did not, by itself, redistribute senior positions, partnership roles or access to the most lucrative cases. Transformation in the sector is therefore about representation as much as the practical opportunities to build a career.
For several years, the authorities have defended measures intended to broaden that access. The Department of Justice has said, in particular, that for the 2023-24 financial year, 95% of cases entrusted by the state had been allocated to previously disadvantaged professionals. But their share of total remuneration stood at 88%, and women’s share at 30%. These figures, presented by the department, concern the state’s legal work: on their own, they do not describe the distribution of partners or income at private firms. Data provided by South Africa’s Department of Justice nevertheless illustrate the importance of the work allocated and its value.
The case also forms part of a recent political trajectory marked by renewed debate over redress policies. Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment rules, often referred to by the acronym B-BBEE, seek to widen black participation in the economy. The legal-sector code was intended to adapt this framework to the specific circumstances of law firms, independent lawyers and access to mandates.
Annulment based on procedure
Adopted on 20 September 2024 by Minister Parks Tau, the code set targets for ownership and representation in the profession. For large firms, it provided, in particular, for black ownership to reach up to 50% over five years, with a particular place reserved for black women. It also covered management, training and the procurement of legal services.
On 7 October 2026, the Gauteng High Court, sitting in Pretoria, overturned the ministerial decision to publish the text and referred the matter back to the minister for reconsideration. It found that Parks Tau had not demonstrated that he had personally exercised the discretion entrusted to him by law. In essence, the Court considered that the minister could not simply endorse choices emerging from the sector’s work without showing how he had assessed the evidence and objections submitted.
This point is essential: the judgment does not rule on the legitimacy of the transformation goals or their constitutionality. Nor does it mean that all sector-specific rules have been set aside. It is the decision to promulgate the code that has been overturned, and the minister must reconsider it. The account of the ruling made public on 8 October specifies that the Court did not rule on the merits of the goals themselves.
The challenge was brought by Deneys, formerly Norton Rose Fulbright in South Africa, and later supported by Bowmans, Webber Wentzel and Werksmans. The Solidarity trade union also joined the proceedings. Hearings were held before the Gauteng High Court in May 2026. The firms challenged the way the code had been adopted and its feasibility, while saying they supported the principle of a framework specific to the profession. The case presented by Deneys before the hearings sets out this distinction between the aim of a code and the version under challenge.
Different effects for different actors
For the government, the annulment requires a new step and delays implementation of the measure in its current form. For the applicant firms, it is a procedural victory, but not a rejection of transformation obligations. The minister can resume the assessment, explain his choices and decide what to do next within the legal framework.
For black lawyers, professional associations and early-career legal practitioners, the uncertainty concerns the levers that will enable them to gain access to positions of responsibility and lucrative mandates. During the hearings, supporters of the code argued that entry into the profession is not enough if opportunities to build a client base, secure work and progress remain unevenly distributed. By contrast, the major firms argued that poorly designed criteria could harm their operations or their relationships with public and institutional clients.
The courts have therefore not adjudicated between these substantive arguments. They have reiterated an institutional requirement: when a law entrusts a decision to a minister, he must exercise his own judgement and make his reasoning clear. The rule applies beyond this case. It governs how the state turns political objectives into enforceable standards.
A ruling to watch beyond Gauteng
The ministerial reconsideration will be the next step. It remains to be seen whether the code is revised, retained with new reasons or replaced by a different measure. Discussions between the department, the Legal Practice Council and representative organisations will shape the form of future rules. The government had defended the text as a way to support the participation of black professionals, particularly women and young lawyers.
The implications extend beyond major firms in Pretoria and Johannesburg. Decisions on the allocation of public mandates, training for young practitioners and progression to partnership also determine who will be able to build a lasting client base in other urban centres and beyond. The question is particularly concrete for smaller practices, which do not have the same resources as large firms to absorb new requirements.
Regionally, South Africa is a member of the Southern African Development Community (SADC), which brings together states co-operating on several regional issues. The judgment does not change SADC rules. It does, however, underline that economic transformation policies must rest on sound procedures and verifiable reasoning. At continental level, the case highlights a shared challenge: widening access to influential professions without separating the goal of equality from the rule of law.



