In Rome, a verdict has marked a significant judicial milestone in a case that has poisoned relations between Italy and Egypt for ten years. On 28 September 2026, three Egyptian agents were sentenced to ten years in prison for the abduction of Giulio Regeni. A fourth defendant was acquitted.
Ruling delivered ten years after disappearance in Cairo
Giulio Regeni disappeared in Cairo on 25 January 2016. Aged 28, the Italian researcher was preparing a thesis at the University of Cambridge. His research focused in particular on independent trade unions and social movements in Egypt.
His body was found on 3 February 2016 by the roadside between Cairo and Alexandria. Italian investigators reported numerous signs of violence. Italy’s courts later adopted the theory that he had been abducted, detained and tortured. The exact circumstances of his death, however, remain at the centre of the dispute between Rome and Cairo.
Rome’s Assize Court convicted Magdi Ibrahim Abdelal Sharif, as well as Colonels Uhsam Helmi and Athar Kamel Mohamed. The three men were found guilty of aggravated abduction. General Tariq Sabir was acquitted.
The conviction does not concern the murder of Giulio Regeni. The court did not find the three convicted defendants guilty of that offence. Rome prosecutors had sought a life sentence for Magdi Ibrahim Abdelal Sharif and 17 years and six months in prison for the other three defendants.
The four defendants, who remained in Egypt, never appeared before the Italian judges. The trial took place in their absence. The proceedings were made possible by a ruling from Italy’s Constitutional Court, which allowed the case to go ahead despite difficulties in notifying the defendants of the charges.
Judicial cooperation at a standstill
Rome’s chief prosecutor, Francesco Lo Voi, welcomed the verdict. He said the Italian justice system had prevented the case from becoming permanently bogged down. He also criticised what he described as a lack of meaningful cooperation from the Egyptian authorities.
Since the investigation began, Italian magistrates have accused members of Egypt’s security services of playing a role in the abduction, detention and abuse of the researcher. Cairo rejects the allegations. The Egyptian authorities dispute the findings of the Italian investigation and deny any state involvement in Giulio Regeni’s death.
The disagreement has stalled several requests for judicial assistance. Italian investigators sought, among other things, information about Giulio Regeni’s movements, his contacts in Cairo and those who may have been involved in surveilling or detaining him.
The proceedings were also delayed by the impossibility of bringing the suspects before the court. For several years, this prevented the trial from effectively opening in Italy. The Constitutional Court’s ruling ultimately removed that legal obstacle, without resolving the practical question of enforcing any sentences in Egypt.
The verdict is therefore a judicial step forward, but it does not bring the case to a close. The convicted men remain in Egypt. Unless the Egyptian authorities change their position, their arrest and transfer to Italy remain uncertain.
A case extending beyond the criminal proceedings
In Italy, the Regeni case has become a symbol of the search for truth in cases involving security agencies. Since 2016, yellow banners bearing his name have appeared in many cities. They carry his family’s rallying cry: “truth and justice”.
For the researcher’s family, the ruling in Rome marks a milestone after a decade of legal efforts. It does not, however, answer all their questions. A conviction for abduction cannot by itself establish who ordered the violence or the precise circumstances in which Giulio Regeni died.
The case also weighs on bilateral relations. Italy and Egypt have significant ties in energy, trade, security and migration. Tensions have not ended those ties, but have repeatedly resurfaced over judicial cooperation and human rights.
For Egypt, the case is set against a regional environment marked by acute security concerns. Since the political upheavals of the early 2010s, the Egyptian authorities have emphasised the fight against armed groups, institutional stability and the protection of the state. Human rights advocates, meanwhile, highlight the risks associated with opaque detentions and the lack of independent oversight of the security forces.
These two interpretations remain deeply opposed. Italy considers that the evidence gathered by its magistrates justified a trial. Egypt, for its part, rejects the idea that the Italian proceedings can establish responsibility on the part of its institutions. The verdict does not resolve this divide.
A precedent watched beyond the Mediterranean
The significance of the case extends beyond relations between Rome and Cairo. It raises a question followed in many African countries: how can responsibility be established when a case involves state agents, the suspects live in another country and judicial cooperation is limited?
The Regeni case also highlights the limits of national proceedings in the face of cross-border crimes. A court can investigate, try and convict. It cannot always enforce a sentence without the cooperation of the country where the convicted people are located.
The next stage will therefore be as much diplomatic as judicial. Any appeals in Italy, Cairo’s official response and the Italian authorities’ ability to obtain further information will be crucial. Ten years after Giulio Regeni disappeared, the court has delivered a ruling. The question of the full truth remains open.



