A legal battle that goes beyond the migrant issue
In Pretoria, the question is no longer simply one of maintaining order in the streets or tensions surrounding foreigners. It now touches on the responsibility of the South African state, its image on the continent and how South Africa is handling a crisis that has become political, social and diplomatic. A petition filed with the International Criminal Court seeks precisely to move the debate from the local arena into the realm of international law.
The timing is sensitive. For several weeks, the South African government has stepped up operations against irregular immigration, while insisting that violence against foreigners has no place in a democracy founded on Ubuntu and the Constitution. At the same time, several African countries have organised the return of their nationals, a sign that tensions extend well beyond South Africa’s domestic affairs.
What the facts show
Two Ghanaian nationals petitioned the International Criminal Court on 15 July, calling for an examination of violence targeting foreigners in South Africa. Their move is based on the claim that there is a “widespread and systematic” pattern of attacks against migrants, with incidents that could amount to crimes against humanity. The case refers to beatings, killings, looting of businesses and the destruction of homes.
The ICC has yet to rule on the merits of the case. The petitioners are asking the Office of the Prosecutor to open a preliminary examination, the first step in determining whether there is a reasonable basis to proceed to an investigation. The Rome Statute, the Court’s founding treaty, covers crimes against humanity, among others.
South Africa’s response has been firm. The Department of International Relations and Cooperation called the move “opportunistic”, while the presidency and the same department reiterated that only authorised officials may enforce the law, and that vigilante action, violence and intimidation are rejected. The government also insists that migration management must remain in line with the Constitution and the country’s regional and international commitments.
Diplomatically, the case has not come out of nowhere. Ghana had already called for xenophobic violence in South Africa to be placed on the African Union’s agenda, arguing that the issue was of continental concern. Pretoria responded by highlighting the structural causes of migration, governance and regional cooperation.
An African crisis, not just a South African one
Available figures show that the pressure is real, although not all tallies from different sources match. The South African government says it had processed 15,162 Malawian nationals for deportation or repatriation by 25 June, and that more than 40,000 people in the country irregularly had been arrested since 1 January 2026. In mid-July, the South African Police Service also linked 350 arrests to incidents of public violence, intimidation and unauthorised immigration checks.
Returns organised by countries of origin confirm the scale of the movement. Nigeria said it had repatriated nearly 1,500 nationals from South Africa. The Ghana News Agency, for its part, reported evacuations of Ghanaian citizens, followed by a further phase of returns planned from 25 July for around 900 people. These movements have a direct impact on families, as well as on the neighbourhoods where migrants worked, rented, traded or lived.
The stakes for the South African economy are tangible. Mass departures could create labour shortages in some informal or low-skilled sectors, even as the country seeks to bring down already high unemployment. For migrants, the impact is immediate: loss of income, business closures, disruption to children’s schooling and increased dependence on return arrangements that are often improvised.
In this case, the South African government is walking a fine line. On the one hand, it wants to respond to genuine public anger, fuelled by unemployment, pressure on services and informal immigration-control networks. On the other, it must prevent the crackdown on irregular migration from turning into the stigmatisation of African foreigners. The Centre for Human Rights at the University of Pretoria and several civil society organisations have warned of precisely this slide from immigration enforcement to targeted violence.
What the case says about southern Africa
The petition to the ICC has implications beyond South Africa. It tests the ability of African institutions to address, first on the continent, a dispute over human mobility that affects all of southern Africa. The SADC, the Southern African Development Community, is directly concerned, as movement between South Africa, Malawi, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Lesotho, Botswana and Eswatini shapes work, trade and family ties.
It also raises a question of approach for the African Union. Should the crisis be allowed to become a legal matter in The Hague, or should African responses on prevention, consular protection and regional mediation be strengthened first? Pretoria says it favours pan-African dialogue, while some governments of migrants’ countries of origin are calling for a firmer response to repeated attacks on their citizens.
The next development to watch will be the response to the petition by the ICC Office of the Prosecutor, as well as the diplomatic decisions of the African capitals concerned. Meanwhile, South African migration-control measures, repatriation operations and the reactions of human rights organisations will continue to weigh on the country’s domestic stability. In Pretoria and elsewhere, the case is a reminder that sustainable migration policy is judged not only by security, but also by how it protects people’s dignity.



