Forgiveness as a terrain of struggle
In many African countries, the question is not only how to punish. It is also how to rebuild after violence, without erasing victims or allowing society to become locked in revenge. This very concrete debate is brought back to the fore by a documentary about Desmond Tutu, as it opens FIFDA in Paris, a festival dedicated to perspectives from the African diaspora. The screening is scheduled for Friday 4 September 2026, at the CGR Lilas cinema, as part of an edition running from 4 to 6 September.
The subject extends far beyond South Africa alone. Desmond Tutu embodied a moral voice born of the struggle against apartheid, then extended to other tragedies on the continent and around the world. Awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1984 for his role as a leading figure in the non-violent campaign against apartheid, he defended until his death in 2021 an idea that became his hallmark: forgiveness does not replace truth, but it can prevent a country from remaining trapped in a cycle of reprisals.
From apartheid to restorative justice
Tutu’s life and work are set against a South African history marked by apartheid, a system of legally enforced racial segregation introduced after the National Party’s victory in 1948. The film also recalls the impact of Bantu education, designed to confine black pupils to subordinate jobs. This was the setting that prompted Tutu’s transformation, from teacher to Anglican priest and increasingly visible activist. He was ordained in 1961, at the start of a public life that would make him a figure of conscience for the country.
His activism gained new force after the Soweto uprising on 16 June 1976. That day marked a turning point in South African history, as pupils protesting against the imposition of Afrikaans as the language of instruction were met with police repression. The event accelerated the politicisation of a generation and strengthened the role of churches, trade unions and black organisations in challenging the regime. In this national story, Tutu came to occupy a distinctive place: that of a religious leader who spoke of dignity, but also of power relations.
The documentary emphasises this transformation. It presents Tutu not as an abstract figure, but as an intellectual shaped by prayer, doubt and self-examination. His struggle did not stop at apartheid. It extended to the idea of ubuntu, a broadly South African concept that holds that a person is shaped by others, and to restorative justice: reparation that seeks to reintegrate society rather than harden it. This interpretation gives forgiveness a political, as well as a social, dimension: it speaks of coexistence, memory and collective survival.
Rwanda as a moral and political test
One of the most sensitive passages in this story concerns Rwanda. After the 1994 genocide against the Tutsi, the country had to deal with an immense number of cases and a fractured society. The United Nations notes that the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda was established in November 1994 and that, to address mass crimes, Kigali also reinstated the community-based gacaca courts in 2005, intended to bring local truths to light, try defendants and promote a form of reconciliation. Forgiveness was never a simple gesture there; it has always encountered the pain of survivors.
This is precisely where Tutu’s approach proved unsettling. In Rwanda, he argued that society should move beyond pure vengeance. But such a position, after a genocide, first meets resistance from families, survivors and those who must relive events in front of witnesses. The film shows that this tension is no theoretical detail. It cuts to the heart of rebuilding African states after extreme violence: how to uphold the law, make room for truth, and prevent institutional peace from resting on silence?
This debate resonates far beyond Rwanda. In South Africa, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission left a mixed legacy: it produced a public account of apartheid crimes, but also left many expectations unmet. In the United States, where the film recalls the absence of a national truth commission, the question of racial memory remains a live one. Tutu saw this kind of mechanism as a way to name wrongs and provide a foundation for democratic debate. The documentary thus brings out a key idea: truth is not a moral add-on, but political infrastructure.
An African reading of a global legacy
By programming this film as its opening event, FIFDA gives a central place to a reflection that speaks as much to African viewers as to diaspora audiences. The festival, held in Paris on 4, 5 and 6 September 2026, embraces a space for the circulation of black and African memories, linking the continent, the Caribbean, Europe and the Americas. The inclusion of a film about Tutu in this setting is no accident: it connects South African history to contemporary debates about reparation, archives, colonial wounds and transmission.
The subject’s continental reach also lies in its approach. From Dakar to Kigali, Johannesburg to Nairobi, many African societies still face the question of political crimes, unfinished transitions and competing memories. Legal frameworks change, as do institutions. But the same tension remains: is punishment enough to rebuild? Karen Hayes’s film suggests another path, more demanding than forgetting and more political than passing compassion. It runs through truth, recognition of victims and an effort at reintegration that does not confuse forgiveness with amnesty.
Finally, it is worth considering what this legacy says about the place of African figures in the global public sphere. Tutu was not merely a South African symbol. He was a contributor to African political thought on memory, justice and dignity. That is why his image continues to matter, including at a diaspora festival in Paris: it reminds us that African trajectories are not read only through crisis, but also through the ideas that help overcome it.



