On maps, borders seem to leave no gaps. Yet a few territories fall outside state claims — not because they are there for the taking, but because their status stems from particular agreements, rivalries or international rules. Three cases, in Antarctica, between Egypt and Sudan, and between Croatia and Serbia, show why land without recognised sovereignty is not necessarily land available to claim.
A concept to use with caution
The Latin term terra nullius, often translated as “nobody’s land”, refers to a territory claimed by no state. But the phrase can be misleading: the absence of a claim does not mean there are no inhabitants, no rules, or an automatic right for an individual to found a country there.
Its history also calls for caution. Colonial powers invoked the doctrine to justify taking possession, sometimes denying the political systems and rights of people already living there. The term should not turn a history of sovereignty into a story of “empty” lands.
Globally, the largest areas outside national jurisdiction are maritime: the high seas generally begin beyond exclusive economic zones, which extend up to 200 nautical miles from the coast. They cover about 43% of the planet’s surface, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts. This does not mean the sea is without rules: international law governs navigation, fishing and scientific research, among other activities. Pew’s data on the high seas give a sense of the scale of this shared space.
In Antarctica, sovereignty put on hold
Marie Byrd Land, in West Antarctica, is the continent’s largest sector without an official territorial claim. Its area is often estimated at about 1.6 million square kilometres. It is named after Marie Byrd, the wife of American explorer Richard Byrd.
The case falls under a particular international framework. The Antarctic Treaty was signed on 1 December 1959. Seven states — Argentina, Australia, Chile, France, New Zealand, Norway and the United Kingdom — had territorial claims at the time, some of them overlapping. The treaty did not allocate unclaimed sectors: it froze existing positions and prohibited activities carried out while it was in force from creating or strengthening a claim to sovereignty.
Distance and extreme conditions go some way towards explaining why no state has claimed Marie Byrd Land. But the key point is institutional: Antarctica is governed by a framework that prioritises peace and scientific cooperation. Presenting the region as simply “free” territory would overlook these rules. The text and history of the Antarctic Treaty set out the status of territorial claims.
Bir Tawil, the mirror effect of a border dispute
On the border between Egypt and Sudan, Bir Tawil is a desert territory that neither Cairo nor Khartoum officially claims, according to the generally accepted interpretation of the dispute. The situation stems from two boundaries drawn under British administration, in 1899 and then in 1902.
The first mainly follows the 22nd parallel. The second, an administrative boundary, alters the line in the region. The two countries rely on different lines to support their positions on the larger, coastal and disputed Halaib Triangle. But the boundary that favours Egypt’s claim to Halaib places Bir Tawil on the Sudanese side; the one invoked by Sudan places Bir Tawil on the Egyptian side. Claiming Bir Tawil could therefore weaken either country’s position on Halaib.
This paradox does not turn Bir Tawil into a territory without history or stakes. Rather, it shows how a border inherited from the colonial period continues to shape relations between two neighbouring states. An analysis by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace details the link between the two territories and the Egyptian and Sudanese positions. The study of the Egypt-Sudan border dispute recalls that the claims are linked.
Individuals have tried to proclaim sovereignty over Bir Tawil, notably in 2014, by planting a flag there. These initiatives have received no international recognition. An individual declaration is not enough to create a state or settle a dispute between two countries.
Gornja Siga: a micronation confronts real-world borders
Further north, on the Danube, a wooded area called Gornja Siga is at the centre of a boundary dispute between Croatia and Serbia. The disagreement concerns, among other things, how to determine the border: Zagreb refers to historical cadastral boundaries, while Belgrade places greater emphasis on the river’s present course. The area is often featured in accounts of “unclaimed land”, but that description is disputed.
In 2015, Czech political activist Vít Jedlička proclaimed Liberland, a self-declared micronation, there. This initiative does not amount to state recognition. Croatia’s Ministry of the Interior says the area falls within a zone where the two countries’ boundaries are being delimited and that Croatian police carry out legitimate checks there. It also says the border remains a subject of negotiation. Croatia’s official position on the area known as Liberland therefore contradicts the idea that it is legally open to occupation by third parties.
The case shows the difference between a symbolic claim and actual control of a territory. Community projects or online registrations do not settle the dispute between Belgrade and Zagreb. They are no substitute for bilateral negotiations or an agreement recognised by the states concerned.
Exceptions that reveal the rules
These three territories do not have the same status. In Antarctica, a treaty organises coexistence and suspends the effects of claims. Between Egypt and Sudan, two boundaries inherited from British administration sustain a diplomatic calculation around Halaib and Bir Tawil. Between Croatia and Serbia, a self-declared micronation runs up against a border disagreement that Croatian authorities say they continue to treat as a delimitation issue.
The stakes differ at the regional level: scientific cooperation and international governance under the Antarctic system; neighbourly relations and colonial legacies between Cairo and Khartoum; bilateral negotiations in the Balkans. In every case, the absence of a straightforward claim does not create a legal vacuum. It indicates instead that sovereignty depends on agreements, power dynamics and recognition procedures — not merely on planting a flag on a map.



