When a national symbol becomes a selling point
In South Africa, some images must be handled with care. The Women’s March of 9 August 1956 is one of those collective touchstones that go beyond activist memory. It evokes Pretoria, the seat of power, apartheid and a mobilisation that became a cornerstone of the national day dedicated to women.
It was precisely this symbolic capital that a campaign linked to Glenlivet whisky sought to use. The clip, shared online and then withdrawn after the controversy, was seen as a commercial appropriation of a pivotal episode in South African history. The reaction was immediate, because in South Africa the memory of women’s resistance is not an advertising backdrop but a political legacy.
What the 1956 march really represents
On 9 August 1956, around 20,000 women marched to the Union Buildings in Pretoria to protest against the extension of the pass laws, imposed by the apartheid state to control the movement of the Black population. South African historical and official sources describe the day as a defining moment in the struggle against apartheid and in women’s emergence as a visible force in the national resistance.
The march’s significance also lies in its method. It brought together women from several communities and backgrounds around a shared demand for dignity. It gave rise to a phrase that has become emblematic, “Wathint’ abafazi, wathint’ imbokodo”, often translated as “You strike a woman, you strike a rock”. This memory is now part of the South African state’s official calendar, with 9 August designated National Women’s Day and August set aside to recognise women’s contribution to the country’s liberation.
Against this backdrop, linking this history to an alcoholic product offended people far beyond activist circles. It reignited another sensitive issue in South Africa: the role of alcohol in social and domestic violence. South African authorities regularly point out that alcohol abuse fuels gender-based violence and femicide. The government even describes it as a public health and social security problem.
An advertising controversy, but also a wider debate
According to information corroborated by several South African media outlets, the campaign featured South African actor Dineo Langa in a black-and-white montage that moved through portraits of figures from the struggle, including Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, Lilian Ngoyi and Sophie Williams-De Bruyn. The sequence also featured a voice attributed to Winnie Madikizela-Mandela. After it was released, the brand and the actor apologised and the post was deleted.
The controversy went beyond a “poor creative choice”. Sophie Williams-De Bruyn, the last surviving woman among those cited in the campaign, said she had never authorised the use of her image. Families of figures from the march later called for direct explanations about how the project had been conceived, saying that removing the content was not enough to close the matter.
The debate also touches on the country’s economic history. Several responses recalled that alcohol was long used as a tool of control in Black and mixed-race labour areas, notably through the dop system, under which some workers received part of their wages in alcohol. In today’s South Africa, this history continues to shape how brands approach issues of race, labour and dignity.
The ANC also responded, condemning the reduction of the “courageous women” of 1956 to mere marketing symbols. The South African department responsible for women, for its part, stressed that the 1956 struggle could not be separated from the social consequences of alcohol, particularly in a country where gender-based violence remains a national emergency.
Why the affair goes beyond Pretoria
This episode says something broader about southern Africa and, beyond it, about how major global brands engage with African memories. In South Africa, public life remains shaped by the post-apartheid transition, commemorative rituals and strong expectations of fair representation. An advertising campaign that ignores this context can quickly cross a red line: respect for the figures of liberation.
The issue also points to a continental challenge. In several African countries, international companies seek to associate their products with powerful local symbols, often without grasping the political weight of those references. Here, the South African reaction is a reminder that a history of resistance cannot be dissolved into commercial storytelling. It also shows that debates about women, violence, alcohol and public dignity are now closely connected.
For Pretoria and the Southern African Development Community as a whole, the issue is not simply a withdrawn advert. It is about who controls historical narratives, how brands use symbols of liberation and how far memory can be turned into a consumer image. In this case, the response from the South African public was clear: the 1956 march belongs to the country’s political history, not to marketing.



