Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Subscribe

CultureEdition South AfricaSouth Africa

In Arles, Thato Toeba links Lesotho’s archives to the mining tragedies haunting southern Africa

At the Rencontres d’Arles, Basotho artist Thato Toeba turns the archive into a critical tool, linking the memory of illegal South African mines to silences surrounding Lesotho’s history.

Editorial team in Maseru with journalists and press equipment around blurred screens and microphones.

In Arles, an artwork about archives — and, above all, lives erased

In the abandoned mines of South Africa’s basin, there is more than gold, dust and unstable tunnels. There are also families counting those who are missing, compensation procedures that drag on, and a Basotho working-class memory still too often told from the outside. Thato Toeba’s work sits at the intersection of these threads. The artist, who was born in Maseru, Lesotho, is presenting work this year at the Rencontres d’Arles. The festival says the exhibition, installed in the Henri-Comte room, is open from 6 July to 4 October 2026.

The starting point is concrete. Toeba draws on a recent tragedy linked to illegal mining in South Africa, where clandestine miners, several of them from Lesotho, were found dead in a disused shaft. South African authorities spoke of dozens of victims in 2023, while the Stilfontein crisis in 2024 underscored the scale of the phenomenon and its human cost. In the region, the subject is therefore more than an artistic anecdote. It touches on cross-border labour, economic survival and the dignity of Basotho workers.

Lesotho and its South African neighbour

Lesotho is a kingdom entirely surrounded by South Africa. This geography shapes its economy, its patterns of movement and its social imagination. For decades, Basotho men worked in South African mines, first in formal employment and later, some of them, in the grey or clandestine economy as jobs became scarce and mines closed. The consequences are still visible today in the country’s rural areas, in households without a stable income and in compensation claims related to silicosis and tuberculosis.

This reality is not only social; it is institutional. The Basotho government continues to support registration and compensation campaigns for former miners through the Tshiamiso Trust. In July 2025, the Lesotho News Agency reported that the organisation had launched a field campaign in Botha-Bothe to register and locate former Basotho miners eligible for compensation for occupational diseases. The agency said more than 400 people had been seen on the first day in that district alone. In June 2026, the same source reported that the fund had already paid more than one billion loti to former Basotho miners and their dependants.

At the same time, South African authorities have stepped up the fight against illegal mining. The South African Department of Mineral Resources said 42 deaths were recorded in legal mines in 2024, the lowest level ever observed in the country, highlighting the contrast between reported progress in the formal sector and the persistent danger of abandoned shafts. On the ground, the police and military campaign known as Vala Umgodi, “close the hole”, has been presented as a response to illegal gold mining. But the strategy has also sparked fierce debate about the treatment of miners trapped underground, particularly at Stilfontein.

When art enters the battleground of the archives

Thato Toeba’s exhibition approaches this conflict from another angle. The festival’s exhibition notes describe work based on collage, photomontage and the use of found archives. The artist, who is also a lawyer and social sciences researcher, explores the imperial and colonial legacy, with particular attention to South African histories. The festival’s text also says that Toeba was born in 1990 in Maseru, lives and works between Amsterdam, Maseru and Cape Town, and that their approach responds to the scarcity of accessible regional archives, with many African visual collections held in Europe.

This choice is not merely aesthetic. It says something about how African histories are produced, preserved and read. When archives are incomplete, scattered or held by other institutions, their absence becomes a political subject. Toeba turns it into visual material. The fragments, overlays and gaps in the works do not serve to decorate the silence. Instead, they show what has been erased, displaced or misrepresented. This method gives form to an experience widely shared across southern Africa: a memory of labour often better preserved in other people’s administrative records than in national institutions.

The exhibition’s title, Everyone Can Be Lucifer, adds another layer of tension. It does not point to a single culprit. It questions the shifting line between victim, accomplice, survivor and system. In the case of clandestine miners, this ambiguity is central. The men who descend into these shafts often do so to survive. Local economies that depend on this income turn a blind eye, while states try to enforce the law without causing new tragedies. The result is a grey area where repression, poverty and informality intersect.

What the subject says about Lesotho and southern Africa

For the Basotho, the issue is not abstract. It touches on families, pensions and occupational diseases, but also on recognition. Mining has sustained entire generations while leaving behind scarred bodies and incomplete archives. That is why Toeba’s work resonates beyond the Arles festival. It compels viewers to see Lesotho not as a periphery, but as a country whose social history is deeply intertwined with the South African economy.

This perspective also matters to SADC, the Southern African Development Community, whose member states share labour flows, mining value chains and common border security challenges. The crises of abandoned mines, precarious workers and incomplete compensation are therefore not confined to a single state. They expose the fragility of a regional model in which the benefits of extraction circulate more freely than social protections. In this context, Toeba’s installation serves as a reminder: photography can document, but it can also challenge how history has been categorised.

Its continental significance lies here. As southern Africa debates mining formalisation, workplace safety and the movement of workers, the Basotho case shows that the issue is not only economic. It is also about memory and politics. The coming weeks will show whether the debate remains confined to South Africa’s abandoned shafts or prompts broader reflection on the place of former miners, African archives and social justice in the region.

Automatic translation. Original French version

The quiz

African cultures: the quiz

6 questions