Sunday, November 22, 2026

Subscribe

EconomyEdition South AfricaSouth Africa

South Africa: Pretoria seeks to make countries of origin pay for migrant returns

Pretoria is seeking financial contributions from Malawi, Nigeria and Ethiopia towards migrant repatriations. The bill is close to 300 million rand, reviving regional tensions.

Newsroom in Johannesburg with anonymous journalists, cameras and blurred screens in a busy editorial setting.

A bill that goes beyond migration

In Pretoria, the issue is no longer just border control. It now touches on public finances, diplomatic relations and how South Africa wants to manage the mass departures of foreigners in an irregular situation or fearing violence. In a country with a long history of regional mobility, the current tensions show how quickly a migration crisis can become a matter of public spending and diplomatic leverage.

The South African government says it has borne most of the costs linked to repatriations and deportations carried out since June 2026, even as several countries concerned have already begun organising the return of their own nationals. This comes as South Africa hosts preparatory meetings in Durban for the 46th Southern African Development Community (SADC) summit, scheduled for 17 August 2026.

What Pretoria says it has paid

According to South African authorities, repatriation and deportation operations have cost close to 300 million rand, or about €16 million. The largest expense is the hire of buses, but the bill also includes setting up and running a temporary processing centre in the north of the country, as well as security and staffing costs. The director-general of the Department of Home Affairs presented the figures to a parliamentary committee this week, describing them as “unforeseen and unavoidable” costs.

The South African government says it has sent compensation requests to Malawi, as well as to the embassies of Nigeria and Ethiopia. The move is part of a doctrine now openly espoused: when foreign nationals leave the country following a crackdown on irregular migration, Pretoria believes their countries of origin should share the logistical burden. The executive, for its part, points out that under normal arrangements, the countries requesting returns bear primary responsibility for transport and organising voluntary returns.

South African authorities have also stressed that operations since mid-June 2026 have been on an unusual scale. The government says it deported or facilitated the return of more than 68,000 people between 14 June and 24 July, the vast majority of them Malawians, before reducing the capacity of the temporary centre in Musina from 1 August, signalling a slowdown in the flow. Other figures published by neighbouring governments cite even higher numbers of departures over the recent period as a whole.

Malawi, Nigeria, Ethiopia: sensitive diplomacy and a quiet stand-off

The most delicate issue concerns Malawi. Blantyre has already helped organise the return of its nationals, but the scale of departures has put the country under logistical pressure. Malawian authorities have acknowledged the arrival of thousands of their citizens since the crisis began, while figures reported by the international press are far higher than the South African data alone. This discrepancy shows how fluid migration figures remain when they combine administrative expulsions, voluntary returns and departures prompted by fears of attacks.

For Nigeria and Ethiopia, the issue is also diplomatic. Pretoria is now asking them to reimburse transport or temporary accommodation costs, while Lagos and Accra had already said they would seek compensation for damage suffered by their nationals in South Africa. The disagreement is therefore about more than the bill itself: who is responsible for protecting migrants when regional mobility, vital to the informal economy, becomes a source of domestic tension?

The South African executive puts forward a simple argument: it is protecting public order, but does not want to bear alone the cost of a crisis whose effects extend beyond its borders. This reasoning also resonates with some in the local public, who are sensitive to pressure on informal work, housing and public services. But it is also fuelling regional unease, as several SADC states see this tougher stance as a political signal to African migrants, even though the sub-region relies heavily on labour mobility.

What southern Africa is watching now

The developments come as SADC meets in Durban. The Council of Ministers and the summit of heads of state are due to discuss regional cooperation, integration and security, amid a climate in which migration has once again become a test of practical solidarity. South Africa, the region’s economic powerhouse, wants to show that it can control its borders without compromising legality. Neighbouring states, however, are waiting for answers on the protection of their nationals and the true cost of returns organised in haste.

At a deeper level, the issue says a great deal about the state of southern Africa today. On the one hand, governments are tightening controls, expulsions and temporary centres. On the other, regional economies continue to depend on mobile workers, often employed in construction, cross-border trade and urban services. The question is therefore not only one of irregularity, but of a regional model in which borders remain open to economic flows while tightening whenever political pressure rises.

The continental implications are clear. If Pretoria succeeds, other African capitals could be tempted to charge countries of origin more systematically for the cost of expulsions. If, on the other hand, the request is rejected or only partly accepted, SADC will have to find a more stable framework for returns, consular protection and the handling of foreigners in an irregular situation. Either way, the case goes beyond South Africa: it tests the continent’s ability to treat migration as a matter of shared governance, rather than a succession of bilateral incidents.

Automatic translation. Original French version

News quiz

Edition South AfricaSouth Africa: the news quiz for 13–15 November

5 questions