Sunday, November 22, 2026

Subscribe

PoliticsEdition South AfricaSouth Africa

South Africa backs international justice, but pressure on ICC exposes system’s limits

Navi Pillay’s Nobel Peace Prize puts tensions surrounding the International Criminal Court back in the spotlight. From South Africa, her career raises questions about states’ ability to defend impartial justice in the face of political pressure.

Passers-by talk in a public space in Pretoria, near a contemporary institutional building in South Africa.

When an international court investigates war crimes, its ability to act also depends on the cooperation of states. This balance of power is at the heart of South African jurist Navi Pillay’s advocacy: international law protects no one if it remains a promise without consequences.

A jurist shaped by South African history

At 85, Navi Pillay receives the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize for her commitment to peace and international law. The award was announced on 9 October. It comes as the International Criminal Court (ICC), which prosecutes people suspected of the most serious crimes, faces strong political pressure.

Pillay’s career links South African national justice to international tribunals. A lawyer under apartheid, she defended opponents of the regime. She later became the first Black woman to sit on her country’s High Court, then a judge at the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. This UN tribunal issued the first international conviction for genocide in 1998. The biography published by the ICC traces these milestones.

In an interview with the Associated Press in The Hague, the jurist described the award as recognition of collective work. She warned that the weakening of the rule of law exposes every country to conflicts with fewer checks. “If states or warlords start launching wars individually, it is chaos,” she said. Her warning rests on a simple principle: without institutions capable of establishing the facts and enforcing the law, force risks becoming its own arbiter.

The ICC at the centre of a political standoff

The award comes amid a confrontation over international criminal justice. In February 2025, Donald Trump signed an executive order providing for sanctions against the ICC and people associated with its work. Washington disputes the Court’s jurisdiction in cases involving US or Israeli nationals. The United States is not a member of the Rome Statute, the treaty that established the ICC.

Pillay described the US measures discussed in the interview as “totally illegal” and “negative and cruel”. These are her assessments, not a judicial ruling establishing their illegality. The ICC, for its part, has rejected US sanctions as an attack on the rule of law. The US executive order and the Court’s response shed light on both sides’ positions in this dispute.

The jurist highlights a broader tension: several powers wield considerable diplomatic influence, particularly on the UN Security Council, without being parties to the Rome Statute. The United States and Russia can also exercise their veto on the Council. The ICC, meanwhile, depends largely on states’ cooperation to arrest those it targets and enforce its decisions. This structure fuels criticism of unequal accountability under international law.

For African countries, the debate is not abstract. South Africa has joined the Rome Statute and incorporated its implementation into domestic law. Pretoria must therefore reconcile its legal obligations, diplomatic choices and court rulings. Its experience also serves as a reminder that international justice is not merely an external instrument: African jurists and institutions have helped build it.

Gaza: an investigative finding, not a judgment

Pillay also chaired the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel. In its report published on 16 September 2025, the commission concluded that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza. This conclusion was reached by a Human Rights Council commission of inquiry. It is not a criminal judgment handed down by a court.

Israel and the United States dispute this characterisation. The difference between an inquiry and a trial matters: the commission sets out findings and legal analysis, while a court rules on a case according to its jurisdiction and procedures. The UN report and Navi Pillay’s presentation of its findings help distinguish between these levels of decision-making.

The jurist stresses the examination of facts, statements by officials and observed acts. She notes that prevention lies at the heart of the Genocide Convention. In other words, the purpose of the law is not only to punish after the event. It is also to identify risks and press states to act before violence escalates.

What Southern Africa can take from this

For South Africa, this issue is part of a trajectory shaped by the post-apartheid transition and a foreign policy that champions multilateral institutions. Pretoria is the country’s political capital. In the region, the Southern African Development Community (SADC) brings together states facing, to varying degrees, questions of judicial cooperation, stability and sovereignty. It does not replace international courts, but its members’ choices affect their ability to secure practical cooperation.

The issue’s continental significance goes beyond South Africa’s borders. The African Union also upholds the principle of an international order in which rules apply without double standards. But African governments do not always share the same approach to the ICC. The question is therefore as much political as it is legal: how can impartial justice be supported while addressing criticism of selectivity and diverging national interests?

The award to Pillay does not resolve these disagreements. Rather, it brings one question to the fore: will states accept that the same principles apply to their allies as to their adversaries? The answer will be measured in actions — cooperation with investigations, respect for judicial decisions and protection of institutions from reprisals. For Pillay, the connection remains essential: “Peace requires justice.”

Automatic translation. Original French version

The quiz

African institutions: the quiz

6 questions