Sunday, November 22, 2026

Subscribe

NewsEdition KenyaKenya

Kenya: Shakahola verdict convicts 29, reigniting debate on child protection and religious freedom

Paul Mackenzie and 28 co-defendants were found guilty of 191 murders, including those of 190 children. In Kenya, the ruling has revived questions about preventing abuse and regulating religious organisations.

Unidentified Kenyan professionals gather outside a Mombasa court after the verdict in the Shakahola case

In Kenya, the Shakahola case raises a question that goes beyond the verdict: how can worshippers be protected from coercion without giving the state the power to decide which beliefs are legitimate? On 19 October 2026, the courts answered on the criminal front. The debate on prevention, however, remains open.

A verdict for the Shakahola dead

The High Court in Mombasa found Paul Nthenge Mackenzie and 28 co-defendants guilty of 191 murders. The victims recorded in these proceedings were 190 children and one adult. Judge Diana Kavedza Mochache found that the prosecution had established the guilt of all 29 defendants. The verdict was delivered on Monday 19 October, after a trial that began in 2023.

The case concerned deaths in Shakahola forest, in the coastal county of Kilifi. According to evidence accepted by the court and reported by Kenyan media, the accused took part in a system of indoctrination and forced fasting. Worshippers were reportedly urged to go without food in the hope of “meeting Jesus”. Children, who could not consent to such deprivation, were among the victims.

The ruling settles a significant part of the case, but it does not account for the total number of deaths linked to the site. More than 400 bodies have been exhumed in Shakahola since graves were discovered in 2023. The 191 murders fall within the scope of these specific proceedings and should not be confused with all the deaths found or recorded in the area. The Kenyan report on the verdict and the Associated Press report confirm the number of defendants, the date and the number of victims in this case.

Details of the investigation describe a tragedy with multiple causes. Most of the deaths were reportedly due to starvation, but post-mortems also identified other causes, including injuries and asphyxiation. Allegations and evidence must be distinguished from judicial findings: the verdict concerns the people and charges tried, while investigations into the other deaths are proceeding separately.

A tragedy exposing national failures

Shakahola came to public attention in April 2023, after reports of disappearances and the discovery of shallow graves. Mackenzie led the Good News International Church. He had settled his followers in a remote area, away from public view. The discovery of hundreds of bodies raised questions about public oversight, the response of local authorities and the handling of warnings before police intervened.

The Kenyan parliament opened an inquiry into the proliferation of religious organisations and the circumstances surrounding the first reported deaths. Its report proposed a legal framework to regulate these organisations. But the issue is sensitive: Kenya’s constitution protects freedom of conscience and does not recognise a state religion. Religious leaders and civil liberties advocates fear that overly broad regulation could be used to control beliefs rather than prevent abuse.

The distinction is essential. A state can investigate offences, protect minors and punish coercion without establishing an official religious doctrine. The challenge is to act early enough to address violence and imposed isolation, while preserving Kenyans’ right to practise their faith. The report of the Senate ad hoc committee documents this tension between prevention and religious freedom in detail.

The consequences are not the same for everyone. Children depend entirely on adults for access to food, healthcare and safety. The families of those missing, often dispersed between Nairobi and the coastal regions, must also contend with the identification of bodies and legal proceedings. In rural areas, distance from services and the difficulty of reporting a situation can delay intervention. The ruling acknowledges the seriousness of the established acts, but it does not replace protection systems or support for survivors and relatives.

Next legal steps and the regional dimension

The criminal convictions do not bring all proceedings related to Shakahola to a close. Separate cases concern other offences and victims. The next announced step in this murder case is sentencing, scheduled for 6 November 2026. The sentence will show the immediate legal consequences, but will not by itself resolve questions about oversight of organisations or institutional responsibility.

For the authorities, the challenge will be to turn the findings of the inquiries into practical measures: respond to missing-person alerts, protect children and intervene in cases of coercion. This requires co-ordination between the police, social services, the courts and local authorities. At the same time, institutions will need to explain the rules being applied and allow public scrutiny, so that prevention does not become an arbitrary restriction of freedoms.

Regionally, Kenya is a member of the East African Community (EAC), which brings together eight states and co-operates on social and legal issues, among others. The case does not prove that a uniform phenomenon exists across the region. It does, however, underscore how the movement of people and religious networks makes the exchange of experience and the protection of rights across borders valuable. The EAC’s official overview describes this framework for regional co-operation.

The 19 October verdict establishes the guilt of 29 people for 191 murders. Shakahola’s lasting significance will also depend on what follows: the sentence handed down, the handling of other cases and the ability of Kenyan institutions to identify situations of coercion earlier, without conflating faith with crime.

Automatic translation. Original French version

News quiz

Edition KenyaKenya: the news quiz for 12–13 November

5 questions