Sunday, November 22, 2026

Subscribe

NewsEdition KenyaKenya

Kenya’s Shakahola verdict tests child protection and religious oversight

In Kenya, 29 people have been found guilty of 191 murders linked to Shakahola. The ruling highlights mechanisms of isolation and coercion, and revives debate over child protection and oversight of religious organisations.

Kenyan travellers wait for a bus at a bus station in the coastal region of Kilifi, near Malindi.

When a religious organisation becomes a place of isolation and coercion, children and families can find themselves without any protection. In Kenya, the Shakahola verdict establishes the criminal responsibility of 29 people for the deaths of 191 victims. It also revives a difficult question: how can abuse be identified without treating freedom of worship as permanently suspect?

A verdict after years of investigation

On Monday 19 October 2026, the High Court found Paul Nthenge Mackenzie and 28 co-defendants guilty of murder in the case. The charges concern 191 victims: 190 children and one adult. Judge Diana Kavedza ruled that the prosecution had proved the defendants’ guilt beyond reasonable doubt, according to Kenyan outlet Citizen Digital and the Associated Press.

The ruling distinguishes these 191 murders from the broader toll of the exhumations. In 2023, operations in Shakahola Forest, in the coastal county of Kilifi, led to the recovery of more than 400 bodies. The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights documented the deaths and the institutional failures linked to the tragedy. The figures therefore do not all cover the same ground: 191 murder charges were tried in this case, while the body discoveries relate to a wider total.

The ruling found that an organised system had developed around Mackenzie’s teachings and fasts imposed until death. According to evidence reported in court, children were allegedly targeted first. People tasked with monitoring followers allegedly prevented some from leaving or eating. The defendants denied the charges. Mackenzie denied forcing his followers to fast, the Associated Press reports.

Forensic evidence attributed 72 deaths to starvation. For 110 bodies, decomposition made it impossible to establish the precise cause of death. The court nevertheless considered the testimony and circumstances sufficient to conclude that the defendants were responsible. This highlights the difficulty of trying crimes committed in an isolated place, where physical evidence may be incomplete.

A case that also implicates institutions

The case came to light in 2023, after an alarming report was followed by police operations and exhumations. But Mackenzie’s legal history began earlier: he had already been arrested in 2017 on charges linked to radicalisation, before being acquitted in that case, according to information reported by Citizen Digital. Earlier warnings raise questions about coordination between the police, local authorities and child protection services.

The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights examined human rights violations and the response of public services. Its report, held by the Kenyan Parliament Library, helps shift the debate: the tragedy concerns not only the practices of a group, but also the ability of institutions to receive a report, investigate and protect vulnerable people.

The trial also involved a significant procedural debate. In 2024, the High Court had asked prosecutors to reduce the number of murder charges. In 2025, the Court of Appeal allowed all 191 charges to proceed, ruling that the law did not cap the number of charges that could be brought against a defendant. This process shows that the conviction rests on proceedings that were contested and examined at several levels, not only on the emotion prompted by the discoveries.

The ruling’s reach extends beyond Mackenzie. The court found that the organisation involved several roles, from supervising followers to concealing graves. It also ruled that criminal responsibility could not be evaded on religious grounds when children were deprived of food and protection. This interpretation puts the duty to protect minors at the centre, including when decisions are made in the name of belief.

Religious freedom and the protection of followers

In Kenya, where communities and faith-based organisations play an important role in social life, the challenge is to prevent abuse without conflating religion with violence. Vaguely worded regulation could undermine freedom of worship and the legitimate activities of religious associations. Conversely, the absence of oversight and reporting mechanisms can leave people isolated and at the mercy of leaders who concentrate authority.

The response therefore cannot be limited to registering or monitoring organisations. It also requires accessible reporting channels, a swift response to alerts, child protection and investigative resources suited to remote areas. For families, the consequences remain tangible: missing relatives, identification procedures and grief without immediate certainty about everyone’s fate. For the authorities, the challenge is to improve prevention without reducing religious communities to a security risk.

The next legal step

The court is due to hand down sentences on 6 November 2026, after a hearing on sentencing arguments scheduled for 30 October. The defendants will then be able to challenge the decision through the applicable appeal channels. Mackenzie also faces other, separate proceedings. Those cases should not be conflated with the conviction handed down on 19 October.

For Kenya, a member of the East African Community (EAC), the case could inform regional discussions on child protection, police cooperation and safeguards for religious organisations. Above all, it is a reminder that receiving a report is not enough: institutions must verify it and act. Progress will be measured as much by the outcome of appeals as by concrete measures to prevent a group from cutting its members off from their families, healthcare and the authorities.

Automatic translation. Original French version

News quiz

Edition KenyaKenya: the news quiz for 12–13 November

5 questions