In Matsapha, people deported from the United States are waiting behind the walls of an Eswatini prison, with no connection to the country to which they were sent. Their situation confronts Eswatini with a sensitive question: can foreign detainees be transferred to a third country and then held there without a local court order?
A discreet deal at the heart of a deportation policy
The case dates back to 14 May 2025. On that day, the government in Mbabane signed an agreement with Washington to receive up to 160 people deported from the United States. According to documents made public by Human Rights Watch and cited by several media outlets, the arrangement included a $5.1 million package intended to strengthen Eswatini’s border management and migration capacities. Documents analysed by Human Rights Watch helped shed light on the terms of the agreement.
The first five men arrived in July 2025. They came from Vietnam, Laos, Yemen, Cuba and Jamaica, among other countries. Further transfers followed. By 27 August 2026, at least 32 people had been sent to Eswatini in five groups, according to independent monitoring by Third Country Deportation Watch. The figure remains below the agreement’s cap of 160 people.
Eswatini’s authorities describe the men as foreign nationals temporarily in their care. They say the men pose no threat to the population and should be regarded as people “in transit”. The US government, for its part, deported them following convictions in the United States or proceedings related to their immigration status. This description does not, however, resolve the central question: their transfer did not take them to their countries of origin.
Detention without an offence committed in Eswatini
The transferred individuals are being held at Matsapha Correctional Complex, near Manzini, the kingdom’s economic capital. They have not been convicted by an Eswatini court. Yet they live in a prison environment, under the responsibility of Eswatini’s correctional services.
The situation prompted Eswatini lawyer Sibusiso Nhlabatsi to take the matter to court. After several refusals of access, the courts recognised his right to meet the detainees. In April 2026, Eswatini’s Supreme Court confirmed that the four men concerned could consult a lawyer, while the authorities argued that they had not been arrested or prosecuted in the kingdom. The Associated Press account of the ruling describes a legal battle that lasted several months.
For the defence, the issue goes beyond access to legal counsel. The men are said to have already served their sentences in the United States for the offences of which they were accused. They have nevertheless found themselves locked up in a country they do not know, sometimes without passports, family networks or a clear release timetable.
Authorities in Mbabane say they want to arrange their return to their countries of origin. That prospect is hampered, however, by refusals or administrative difficulties in several of the countries concerned. In the meantime, the detainees remain dependent on decisions made between Washington, Mbabane and their countries of origin.
In Mbabane, a diplomatic choice becomes a political issue
The case comes at a sensitive time for domestic politics. Eswatini is Africa’s last absolute monarchy. King Mswati III holds much of the political power, while political parties do not take part directly in parliamentary elections. Since the 2021 protests, the country has been going through a period marked by serious tensions over civil liberties and political representation.
Human rights organisations regularly denounce restrictions imposed on opposition figures, activists and journalists. Human Rights Watch highlights the continuing limits on freedom of expression, association and assembly. Against this backdrop, the arrival of foreign detainees at a high-security prison quickly took on national significance.
Eswatini residents and activists have challenged the lack of transparency surrounding the agreement. In particular, they want to know how much the state has actually received, which account the funds were paid into and who oversees their use. The government has given varying answers about the nature of the financial compensation. This uncertainty has fuelled suspicion that the arrangement was concluded without public debate.
Unease also stems from the apparent difference in treatment between the transferred detainees and Eswatini’s prisoners. Some deportees are said to receive better food and have access to television, as well as occasional escorted outings. For a population facing stricter prison conditions, this difference has fuelled a sense of injustice.
The role of SADC put to the test
Eswatini is a member of the Southern African Development Community, or SADC, which brings together 16 countries in the region. The organisation seeks to preserve regional stability, but remains cautious when it comes to criticising the political choices of a member state.
The case of the US deportees therefore raises a regional question. If a state agrees to become a place of detention for a foreign power, what guarantees can SADC demand? The right to a lawyer, the length of detention, the conditions of transfer and parliamentary oversight are not issues for Eswatini alone. They concern the ability of African states to negotiate security agreements without weakening their own rules.
The financial dimension adds to the stakes. For a country with limited budgetary resources, several million dollars can represent a significant contribution. But that sum is not enough to establish the legality of a detention or address citizens’ concerns. It may even widen the imbalance between a major external partner and a small kingdom landlocked between South Africa and Mozambique.
A precedent for relations between Africa and Washington
Eswatini is not the only African country approached by the United States to receive deportees. Ghana, Rwanda, South Sudan and other states have been involved in this policy of transfers to third countries. Each agreement has its own terms, but the mechanism is comparable: Washington removes people from its territory and delegates the management of their future to another state.
For African countries, the question is now one of oversight. A partnership with the United States can bring resources, strengthen diplomatic cooperation or support administrative capacity. It can also create dependence and expose governments to domestic opposition when an agreement remains secret.
In Eswatini, the next stage will be legal and political. The courts will have to continue clarifying the detainees’ rights. The government will have to explain how long they are expected to remain and how the announced funds are being used. SADC, meanwhile, will be watched to see whether it can defend shared principles without bypassing the political realities of southern Africa.
In Matsapha, uncertainty remains total. These men are no longer in the United States, but nor have they settled in a country they can call their own. Their future now depends on an agreement between two governments, under the gaze of an Eswatini society seeking to understand what was decided in its name.



