A disappearance lasting a quarter of a century
In Asmara, the silence surrounding some detainees is not merely a private matter. It also says something about contemporary Eritrea: a state where a political challenge dating back 25 years continues to weigh on entire families, the press and the basic right to know whether a loved one is alive. In a member country of IGAD, the East African organisation, this question remains one of the most persistent blind spots in the Eritrean dossier.
The starting point is well known. In September 2001, eleven senior officials, often known as the G-15, were arrested after calling for the implementation of the constitution adopted in 1997 and for national elections to be held. Independent journalists were arrested in the same crackdown. Since then, human rights organisations and UN mechanisms have described their detention incommunicado, without trial or reliable information about their fate.
This is the story now carried by the children of two prominent G-15 figures, who have grown into adults without a clear answer from the Eritrean state. Their accounts recall a simple and brutal reality: the issue in this case is not only political memory. It is families’ right to know where their loved ones are being held, what condition they are in, and even whether they are alive. In 2024, the UN again requested official information about these enforced disappearances and those detained since 2001.
Asmara, 2001: when reform became a red line
To understand this case, it is necessary to return to the post-independence context in Eritrea. Eritrea became independent from Ethiopia in 1993, after a long war of liberation. Power remained concentrated around the People’s Front for Democracy and Justice, while the constitution ratified in 1997 was never implemented and no national election has been held since independence. This absence of elections is at the heart of the criticism voiced by the reformers arrested in 2001.
Political repression took hold just as the country was emerging weakened from the border war with Ethiopia, fought between 1998 and 2000. Human Rights Watch and the UN both link internal repression to the rise of a security system centred on loyalty, prolonged conscription and the closure of public space. The independent press was dismantled in 2001. The journalists arrested at that time remain among the country’s best-known missing people.
The detention sites cited by NGOs have featured in the same accounts for years: Karshelli, in the heart of Asmara, for some female detainees; Eiraeiro, sometimes spelt Ela-Ero, in the east of the country, for several members of the G-15 and journalists. Public sources have never, however, made it possible to establish independently the exact condition of each detainee. It is precisely this information vacuum that turns a political case into one of enforced disappearance.
What this case says about Eritrean power
The G-15 case also sheds light on how power works in Asmara. Internal criticism is not treated as ordinary political disagreement, but as an existential threat. UN and NGO reports indicate that, as recently as 2024, the human rights situation was still marked by arbitrary detention, enforced disappearances and severe restrictions on freedom of expression and association. In July 2024, the UN Human Rights Council also renewed its scrutiny of the country.
This rigidity has very tangible effects. For detainees’ families, it creates a double punishment: the absence of a loved one and the absence of any official status. For society, it fuels exile, fear and mistrust. Human Rights Watch estimates that thousands of Eritreans have fled a system in which conscription can become indefinite and procedural rights are weak or non-existent. Regionally, this also feeds migration towards Sudan, Ethiopia, Djibouti and further afield to Europe.
The Eritrean case is therefore of interest far beyond its borders. It raises a question that the African Union and regional organisations cannot relegate to the margins: what is the value of a continental architecture that promotes stability but cannot secure access to detention sites, public trials or official answers to families? IGAD, of which Eritrea is a member, remains a useful forum for dialogue, but an insufficient one as long as the issue of disappearances and accountability sees no concrete follow-up.
Ultimately, this case is not only about political prisoners. It is about a state that has never closed the file opened in September 2001, and a generation that grew up with photographs, memories and conjecture instead of answers. Twenty-five years later, the question remains the same: where are the detainees, what condition are they in, and will the Eritrean justice system ever move out of the informal realm and into the realm of law?



