In Gaborone, the question is no longer whether Botswana has managed its diamonds well. It has done so better than many other producing countries. The challenge is now harder: what can it build when this source of revenue brings in less, while it still finances a large part of the economy?
The global market slowdown is putting this strategy to the test. Demand for natural diamonds has weakened. Prices have fallen. Less expensive, lab-grown stones have also changed consumer expectations. For Botswana, this shift is not simply a mining crisis. It affects public revenues, jobs, foreign-exchange reserves and the prospects of local businesses.
A strong economy, but exposed to a single driver
Since independence, Botswana has forged a distinctive path in southern Africa. Diamond revenues have supported infrastructure, public services and the accumulation of reserves. Debt remained under control for long periods. The country’s institutions have also retained significant credibility with investors.
However, this success has created lasting dependence. According to the International Monetary Fund, diamonds account for about 80 % of the country’s exports, nearly a quarter of gross domestic product and a significant share of state revenues. Data presented when the agreement between Gaborone and De Beers was renewed show the extent of this exposure.
The problem, then, is not poor management of diamond revenues. It is the difficulty of turning those revenues into a sufficiently broad productive base. An economy can keep its public finances in order while remaining vulnerable to an external shock.
The current slowdown illustrates this. Debswana, a company owned in equal shares by the Botswana government and De Beers, has cut production because of rising stocks and weaker demand. The fall in sales directly affects exports, but also the revenues that fund the national budget.
The diamond shock hits a market already transformed
Competition from lab-grown diamonds is not the only cause of the difficulties. It comes amid a market in which jewellery purchases have slowed and distributors are seeking to reduce their stocks. However, these lab-grown stones have established a new price benchmark, particularly among cost-conscious consumers.
The Botswana government is seeking to defend the value of natural stones. It is focusing in particular on their traceability, origin and image as a sustainable product. But this commercial response alone cannot offset a prolonged fall in demand.
The new agreement reached with De Beers in February 2025 is also intended to strengthen the state’s role in marketing. The state-owned Okavango Diamond Company is to sell a growing share of Debswana’s production. Under the announced allocation, the Botswana company will receive 30 % of sales for the first five years, compared with 70 % for De Beers. The 10-year agreement aims to increase the value captured by Botswana.
This change could improve Gaborone’s negotiating power. However, it does not resolve the central question: selling a larger share of a product in decline is not enough to create a diversified economy.
Jobs reveal the limits of the model
The model’s fragility is most apparent in the labour market. Statistics Botswana recorded an unemployment rate of 27.6 % in the first quarter of 2024, up from 25.9 % in the third quarter of 2023. Among young people, the rate reached 38.2 %. National statistics also show youth unemployment rising.
These figures do not mean that the mining sector creates no economic activity. It funds suppliers and services, and generates revenues that support the economy. But it is capital-intensive. Its capacity to absorb a young workforce remains limited.
The situation affects different areas in different ways. Gaborone is home to government bodies, banks, company headquarters and some modern services. In mining towns and rural areas, opportunities are more closely tied to public spending, local trade, livestock farming and income transfers. When mining revenues fall, the effects can therefore spread far beyond extraction sites.
Small businesses are also exposed. They often depend on public contracts, household spending and contracts linked to large mining companies. A fall in government spending or corporate purchases can quickly squeeze their margins, even when the banking system remains stable.
Diversification depends on the region
Botswana is not starting from scratch. Tourism, digital services, agribusiness, livestock farming, food processing, renewable energy and mining services offer practical opportunities. The investment portal of the Southern African Development Community, SADC, also highlights the potential of infrastructure, tourism and mineral processing. SADC presents Botswana as a gateway to southern African markets.
The main constraint is the size of the domestic market. With a limited population, Botswana needs to sell more goods and services to its neighbours. Its membership of SADC and the Southern African Customs Union, SACU, gives it access to a wider economic area, particularly through South Africa.
Regional integration could support agribusiness, transport, financial services and component manufacturing. However, this requires competitive logistics costs, reliable electricity, technical skills and efficient customs procedures. Without these conditions, diversification plans risk remaining confined to planning documents.
A warning for extractive economies
Botswana’s difficulties have implications beyond its borders. They matter to African countries that rely on oil, gas, copper, cobalt, lithium or gold. Good governance remains essential. It protects public reserves and reduces the risk of a crisis. But it cannot replace industrial policy, appropriate training and a network of local businesses.
The International Monetary Fund says Botswana’s dependence on diamonds has increased while diversification has progressed too slowly. Its 2025 analysis recommends removing barriers that constrain private-sector activity.
The World Bank, for its part, described a contraction in Botswana’s economy in 2024 and a further decline in 2025, driven by the combined effects of falling diamond revenues, fiscal pressures and limited progress on diversification. The institution nevertheless sees the crisis as an opportunity to accelerate reforms.
For Gaborone, time is now running short. The new agreement with De Beers could provide additional resources. It could also help fund part of the transition. But success will depend on how those revenues are used: to support sectors capable of exporting, create sustainable jobs and give Botswana businesses a greater role.
Botswana retains important strengths: a strong institutional reputation, a central position in southern Africa and recognised expertise in mining management. The next step will be to turn these strengths into productive capacity. The true measure of its success will no longer be only how well it manages diamonds, but the strength of the economy that follows them.



