Saturday, November 21, 2026

Subscribe

NewsEdition KenyaKenya

Kenya: 200-year sentence for Mackenzie closes trial, but questions over Shakahola victims remain

Mombasa High Court sentences Paul Mackenzie to 200 years in prison for 191 Shakahola-related murders. The verdict marks a judicial milestone, while identifying victims and protecting worshippers remain major challenges.

Travellers wait for a bus at a busy bus station in Mombasa, Kenya, in clear morning light.

In Shakahola, in the coastal county of Kilifi, the case is about more than one man’s sentence. It also raises a difficult question for Kenya: how can worshippers be protected from abuse without turning freedom of religion into a source of generalised suspicion?

On Friday 6 November 2026, the High Court in Mombasa sentenced Paul Nthenge Mackenzie to 200 years in prison for the murder of 191 people. The court had found him guilty on 19 October, along with 28 co-defendants. Prosecutors had sought the death penalty for Mackenzie. Judge Diana Kavedza ultimately handed down a lengthy prison sentence. Associated Press’s account of the hearing confirms the ruling and its main rationale.

A trial for 191 murders amid hundreds of victims

The convictions relate to 190 children and one adult who died between January 2021 and September 2023. According to evidence reported at the hearing, Mackenzie led Good News International and had ordered his followers to fast to death in order to “meet Jesus”. The judge found him to bear primary criminal responsibility, notably for leading his followers to an isolated location and imposing the fatal fast on them.

The other 28 people convicted were accused of taking part in the operation, including by keeping watch over worshippers or digging graves. The ruling concerns the murder charges brought in this trial, not all the deaths recorded at Shakahola. This distinction is essential: the number of bodies recovered far exceeds the number of victims covered by these 191 counts.

The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights (KNCHR) said 429 bodies had been recovered during operations and that more than 600 people were reported missing when it published its report in March 2024. These figures describe the scale of the tragedy at that time; they are not the judicial tally for the trial. Investigations also uncovered deaths by strangulation, head injuries and dehydration, as well as starvation. The KNCHR’s follow-up report also highlights violations of the rights of children and survivors.

Criminal justice and the limits of the death penalty

Kenyan prosecutors had asked the court to sentence Mackenzie to death, given the number of victims and the gravity of the acts. The death penalty remains on Kenya’s statute book, but it is no longer mandatory for murder. In 2017, the Supreme Court ruled that its mandatory application in such cases was unconstitutional: the judge must consider the circumstances and the evidence presented at the sentencing hearing.

Kenya has carried out no executions since 1987, according to sentencing guidelines published by the judiciary. This did not rule out a death sentence, but meant that the decision fell within a framework requiring the punishment to be individualised. The 200-year sentence therefore closes this stage of the trial without ending debate over the proportionality of the punishment, possible appeals or the responsibility of other actors.

The ruling also concerns the functioning of the state. In its investigation, the KNCHR criticised institutions for failures in prevention, the security response and the treatment of vulnerable people. It also called for survivors to receive support and for families to be able to identify and recover the remains. The conviction establishes the criminal responsibility of the defendants tried; by itself, it does not answer all the questions about earlier warnings and the authorities’ response.

Freedom of worship, protection of believers and public accountability

Shakahola has brought to light tensions between freedom of conscience and the duty to protect life. The human rights commission documented the recruitment of worshippers, indoctrination around fasting and coercive practices. It also stressed that religious freedom does not justify violations of the right to life, health or children’s safety.

For families, the consequences extend beyond the length of the sentences: they are still waiting for answers, the identification of relatives and the chance to grieve. Survivors, meanwhile, need medical care, psychological support and a return to their communities without stigma. The KNCHR had highlighted, in particular, rehabilitation needs and difficulties in providing care in the coastal region.

The case has also reignited debate in Kenya over the oversight of religious organisations. Any reform will have to balance the prevention of abuse, proportionate oversight and constitutional safeguards. Too little regulation can allow dangerous practices to develop; overly broad controls risk penalising faith communities with no connection to these crimes. The institutional response should therefore target acts and mechanisms of coercion, rather than belief itself.

An issue for East Africa

At regional level, the case raises questions for the member states of the East African Community (EAC), an organisation for cooperation between neighbouring states. It is a reminder that religious networks and online content cross borders, while protection and emergency-response mechanisms remain largely national. Kenya will have to combine criminal justice, support for victims and prevention, without conflating criminal practices with freedom of worship.

What happens next will depend on appeals, continued support for survivors and public decisions on oversight of religious organisations. Mackenzie’s 200-year prison sentence marks a major verdict. But Shakahola’s broader human toll and the institutional failures identified by the commission remain separate questions that still demand verifiable answers.

Automatic translation. Original French version

News quiz

Edition KenyaKenya: the news quiz for 12–13 November

5 questions