Sunday, November 22, 2026

Subscribe

NewsEdition SudanSudan

Conflicting tolls from Nyala strike highlight challenge of protecting Sudanese civilians

Accounts of the strike on a Nyala market vary widely. Limited access to the city makes it difficult to verify casualties and underscores the risks civilians face in Sudan’s war.

Unidentified civil society members and medical staff gather in Nyala to document the impact of a strike.

In the evening, stalls stay open as long as customers keep coming. In Nyala, in western Sudan, this everyday activity became the scene of an air strike. But the exact toll remains disputed, highlighting the difficulties of documenting violence in a city held by the Rapid Support Forces.

A market caught up in Nyala’s war

Sudan has been at war since April 2023. The conflict pits the Sudanese Armed Forces against the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), a paramilitary group. The fighting has fragmented control of the territory and triggered mass displacement. Khartoum, the country’s capital, is under the authority of the military camp, while Nyala, the capital of South Darfur state, is controlled by the RSF.

Nyala is therefore at the heart of a territorial struggle, but its markets remain places where residents work and obtain supplies. Women selling food and tea make a living there, sometimes near combatants who have gathered in the area. This proximity exposes civilians to strikes without making them combatants.

The region falls within the remit of the Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD), a regional organisation in the Horn of Africa. Sudan resumed full participation in IGAD in February 2026. The African Union and IGAD support an inclusive, Sudanese-led political process and reject the idea of an exclusively military solution.

Conflicting tolls and difficult access to victims

The strike hit Tanqonj market, in the Dumaya neighbourhood of Nyala, on the evening of Monday 26 October, according to several Sudanese and international media outlets. Emergency Lawyers, a Sudanese human rights network, reported 102 deaths and 113 injuries. The group said women and children were among the victims.

However, this figure is not confirmed by all available sources. Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF), which works in Nyala, said its hospital had received 36 bodies after the strike and treated more than 150 injured people. These hospital figures do not necessarily represent the full toll: victims may have been taken elsewhere, and access to information remains difficult.

On 28 October, Radio Dabanga reported that health authorities linked to the RSF administration in Tasis had given a higher toll: 188 deaths and 356 injuries. This estimate is not independent of that administration and remains disputed. The final toll, the identities of all the victims and the precise circumstances of the strike therefore remain to be established.

Attribution also requires caution. Emergency Lawyers and MSF named the Sudanese army as responsible. Witnesses interviewed by the Associated Press described a drone strike at around 8pm. A spokesperson for a force fighting alongside the army, for his part, presented the operation as a targeted attack on RSF recruits. These accounts are no substitute for an independent investigation.

Civilians exposed to a war fought at a distance

Drones allow both sides to strike far beyond the front lines. Their growing use extends the danger to markets, residential neighbourhoods and infrastructure. The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights said drone attacks had killed at least 306 people and injured hundreds more during the first three weeks of October, across several regions of Sudan.

In Nyala, the impact extends beyond those injured. A strike on a market can halt sales, reduce the availability of goods and deprive families of income. Small-scale vendors, who often depend on daily transactions, have little means of coping with a closure or the loss of their stock. For residents, the fear of another attack can also make journeys to shops and health facilities more dangerous.

Verification remains a central challenge. Limited access to the city, insecurity and the lack of consolidated lists all contribute to discrepancies between the tolls. It is therefore necessary to distinguish between bodies received at a health facility, figures announced by local groups and estimates from authorities linked to one side in the conflict. At this stage, none of these figures alone makes it possible to establish the full toll.

A test of the protection of civilians

The strike comes as the UN documents a rise in civilian casualties caused by drones. The phenomenon affects several Sudanese states and is putting pressure on health services, already grappling with an influx of injured people and a lack of resources. Civilians in areas controlled by either side remain exposed, even far from ground fighting.

For IGAD and the African Union, the stated priority remains de-escalation and a political solution for Sudan. Resuming consultations with political actors is not enough to protect residents while strikes continue. The next developments to watch are independent confirmation of the Tanqonj toll, the opening of an investigation into the circumstances of the attack and concrete measures taken by the parties to spare civilians.

Sources consulted: witness accounts and hospital figures reported by the Associated Press, Médecins Sans Frontières situation update from Nyala, discrepancies between tolls reported by Radio Dabanga, UN figures on drone strikes in October, IGAD statement on Sudan’s return to the organisation and African Union position on a political solution in Sudan.

Automatic translation. Original French version

The quiz

Edition SudanSudan in 5 questions

5 questions