In Eastleigh, a commercial district of Nairobi, the urgent question remains whether anyone may be trapped beneath the rubble. But the collapse of a building still under construction on Friday 23 October also raises another question: who was supposed to check that it complied with the plans and safety rules?
Rescuers face information that remains uncertain
The building collapsed at about 1pm along 9th Street. Its floors fell on top of one another, making it harder to reach the lower levels. The basement and ground floor were occupied, including by shops, according to authorities cited by Kenyan media.
The number of people being sought varied as checks continued. On Friday, Interior Minister Kipchumba Murkomen said seven people had been reported missing. He also said that the 67 workers on site had been accounted for. The Kenya Red Cross, meanwhile, had received 31 reports of people who could not be found, while noting that it still needed to verify them with their families. The figures therefore do not necessarily refer to the same group.
On Saturday 24 October, two people were pulled alive from the rubble several hours apart and taken to hospital. Rescue teams continued their search using machinery and locating equipment, proceeding cautiously to limit the risk of another collapse. The Red Cross and the authorities were co-ordinating the operation with Nairobi services and national teams.
In an area where residents, traders, customers and workers come together, the human toll does not depend solely on the list of workers. Families are still trying to find out whether their relatives were in the shops or nearby. Until reports are matched against those found, the number of missing people remains provisional.
Permits, plans and inspections at the centre of questions
Nairobi Governor Johnson Sakaja said the county’s authorisation covered a change of use for the building, not the architectural plans subsequently submitted. According to reports in the Kenyan press, he said those plans had not been approved. This distinction will need to be examined by the investigation: on its own, it does not establish the cause of the collapse or any individual’s responsibility.
The Engineers Board of Kenya has announced an investigation into possible contributing factors and the role of engineers linked to the project. Police are also investigating. The authorities will need to establish which plans were submitted, which versions were authorised, whether inspections took place and whether the work carried out matched the approved documents.
These checks concern an entire chain of responsibility. The county has a role in urban planning and local permits; the National Construction Authority oversees the sector; and professionals must supervise work within the scope of their mandate. The investigation will need to clarify how these checks were co-ordinated on this site, without presuming that any of these institutions has already been found at fault.
Industry representatives have publicly questioned the frequency and traceability of inspections. This is a practical issue: an inspection is effective only if it takes place at the right time, is documented and is followed by action when work departs from the rules. The findings will therefore need to be based on verifiable evidence, not just statements made after the disaster.
A known vulnerability, but causes yet to be established
Building collapses have concerned Kenyan authorities for several years. A campaign by the Architectural Association of Kenya, drawing on data attributed to the National Construction Authority, cited 87 collapses over five years and about 200 deaths. This historical toll does not establish the cause of the Eastleigh disaster. It does, however, underline that the safety of construction sites and completed buildings remains a long-term concern, particularly in rapidly growing cities.
Public discussion often points to the quality of materials, compliance with standards, technical supervision and enforcement of regulations. In Eastleigh, none of these can be presented as an established cause before the expert findings are available. The inquiry will also need to distinguish between possible design faults, changes during construction, defective workmanship or failures in oversight: these possibilities are not interchangeable.
Pressure is especially acute in districts where homes, workshops and shops stand side by side. An evacuation or the closure of neighbouring buildings can disrupt small traders’ businesses and deprive employees of income. Conversely, allowing activities to continue in a potentially unstable building would expose occupants and passers-by to further danger. Safety decisions therefore have immediate consequences well beyond the construction site.
A test for Kenyan urban governance
In Kenya, urban planning is a shared responsibility between national authorities and county governments. The debate therefore goes beyond identifying an owner or contractor: it also concerns oversight capacity, the sharing of information and the ability to enforce decisions. The governor has called for more deterrent sanctions and greater prosecutorial powers for counties. This is a political position; any changes will depend on institutional processes and decisions.
At the regional level, Nairobi is a major metropolis in the East African Community (EAC), an organisation that brings neighbouring countries together for economic and political co-operation. The collapse alone does not allow conclusions to be drawn about practices across the region. It nevertheless highlights a challenge shared by expanding cities: developing housing and commercial space without weakening the checks that protect residents.
Two steps are now critical: completing the search operation and publishing documented findings on permits, plans and inspections. The Engineers Board and investigative agencies will need to establish the facts before individual or institutional responsibility can be assigned. For families, traders and Eastleigh residents, the priority remains receiving reliable updates and finding out whether neighbouring buildings pose a risk.
Information on the rescue operation and statements by the authorities was cross-checked with Citizen Digital, The Star and the Associated Press. Information on permits and the professional investigation was reported by The Standard and The Star.



