In Kenya, the debate around Rafiki is no longer playing out only on screens. It raises a fundamental question: how far can the state regulate a work without stifling creative freedom? But contrary to reports circulating, the Supreme Court has not recently been asked to decide the case. The key judicial development known to date is a Court of Appeal ruling delivered in January 2026.
A film becomes a constitutional case
Directed by Kenyan filmmaker Wanuri Kahiu, Rafiki tells the story of a romantic relationship between two young women in Nairobi. In April 2018, the Kenya Film Classification Board (KFCB), the public body responsible for classifying and regulating films, banned its screening in the country. It said the feature depicted a lesbian relationship contrary to Kenyan laws and cultural values.
The film had, however, been granted a production licence. The challenge therefore went beyond the fate of a single work: Kahiu and figures from the creative sector took the matter to court, citing, among other things, the freedom of expression and creative freedom guaranteed by the 2010 Constitution. The dispute went through several stages in Nairobi, involving High Court decisions and appeals.
The High Court dismissed the petition in 2020. It held that the plaintiffs should first have used the appeal process provided for under the Films Act, while also finding that the classification framework and the KFCB’s decision could stand. The director appealed to the Court of Appeal.
What the Court of Appeal actually decided
On 23 January 2026, the Court of Appeal of Kenya ruled that the High Court had erred in finding that the constitutional challenge had been brought prematurely. According to the ruling, an earlier decision made during the proceedings had already recognised the High Court’s jurisdiction. The court could not therefore revisit that question when delivering its final judgment.
The Court of Appeal also found that the administrative appeal mechanism provided for by law was not sufficient to determine the constitutional questions raised. In other words, the possibility of challenging a decision before the administration does not automatically bar access to the courts when fundamental rights are at stake.
But this procedural victory does not mean that the judges struck down the classification system as a whole or definitively found that the ban on Rafiki violated the Constitution. The ruling maintains that freedom of expression is not absolute and that certain restrictions may be justified. It also upholds most of the contested provisions governing film classification. The case is therefore more nuanced than a simple lifting of the ban.
The decision and its limits can be checked in the text of the Court of Appeal of Kenya’s ruling and in the legal analysis by Columbia Global Freedom of Expression. These documents confirm that this is a Court of Appeal decision, not a recent Supreme Court judgment.
Creation, classification and fundamental rights
At the heart of the dispute is an important distinction: depicting a subject in a work does not necessarily mean promoting it. Kahiu’s lawyers argued for the right to tell a story, while the KFCB invoked its regulatory mandate and duty to protect the public. The courts must now examine these arguments within the constitutional framework, without conflating a film’s content with a criminal offence.
The legal context is sensitive. Kenyan law criminalises certain sexual acts between men, notably under section 162 of the Penal Code. This provision does not, in itself, make an orientation or identity an offence. The debate around Rafiki concerns the censorship of an artistic representation and the scope of the regulator’s powers; it does not, by itself, determine the legality of all criminal provisions or the rights of LGBTQ+ people.
For creators and cultural businesses, the stakes are also practical. A nationwide ban can limit revenue, a film’s circulation and the public’s access to works produced in their own country. By contrast, age ratings or targeted restrictions are less sweeping options that courts may have to consider when assessing whether a measure is proportionate.
Implications for East Africa’s cultural industries
The path taken by Rafiki resonates beyond Kenya. The country is a member of the East African Community (EAC), which brings together several states in the region around goals of economic integration and cooperation. National decisions on the circulation of films affect artists, producers and distributors seeking to reach regional audiences, even though each country retains its own classification rules.
The case also highlights a tension common to cultural industries: works travel easily through festivals and platforms, while their distribution remains subject to national laws and authorities. For Kenyan filmmakers, the point to watch now is what happens next in the substantive appeal, particularly how the courts apply the principle of proportionality to restrictions imposed on films.
The next step should not be presented as a verdict already delivered by the Supreme Court. At this stage, the January 2026 ruling mainly clarifies where and how constitutional challenges can be heard. The central question — whether the ban on Rafiki was justified in light of the rights protected by the Constitution — remains separate from this procedural decision.



